Welcome to The Sprout! Please sign up or login

Film Review: Asylum

Posted by CeefaxOfLife from Cardiff - Published on 21/08/2015 at 11:05
0 comments » - Tagged as Health, Movies

  • Photo 1
  • Asylum DVD Cover

Asylum is a 1972 fly-on-the-wall documentary that follows the lives of the residents of the Archway Community in London, a commune-cum-squat with bizarre slogans painted on the walls, exposed masonry and not a hoover in sight.

The residents of Archway were people with schizophrenia and psychiatrists. It was a pioneering yet controversial approach to the treatment of mental illness, instigated by R.D. Laing and the Philadelphia Association, which rejected the use of anti-psychotic medication and put no barriers between patients and professionals.

Laing has been called 'the high priest of anti-psychiatry' due to his belief that schizophrenia was a rational response to intolerable experiences and that the garbled out-pouring of people experiencing psychosis could hold the key to the treatment of their schizophrenia.

(Laing was also called 'the acid-Marxist', as he advocated the use of LSD, though there are no signs of this at Archway or in Asylum.)

We witness these behaviours and out-pourings first-hand through the dominating David, the main focus of the film, which climaxes with a kind of intervention involving all the residents of Archway.

Asylum leaves the decision of whether Laing's methods are effective or appropriate to the viewer; we see the benefits of the residents helping each other and themselves, yet this is countered by the risks of such an open policy - sporadic (off-screen) violence and the temporary disappearance of one resident when an uncle comes to take her away.

Asylum remains a fascinating and intriguing insight into schizophrenia, Laing's methods and human interaction. I also found it interesting seeing how alien the past looks; the cars, the food packaging, the smoking and in particular Jamie's father, who was possibly an anachronism at the time, with his Queen's English, his pin-stripe suit and his you sees.

Asylum was released on DVD for the first time this month and if you're wondering why a 1972 documentary has been giving this treatment then the Glaswegian-born Laing is set to played by David Tennant in a biopic called Metanoia, which starts filming next year. 

Want to win a Sprout T-shirt? Fill in theSprout Satisfaction Survey!

Events /// August 2015's Sprout Editorial Group Meeting

Info /// Health /// Emotional and Mental Health 

Organisations /// Barnardo's - Transitions

Articles /// Categories /// Health

Organisations /// Cardiff Mind


Related Articles:

Got something to say?

You must be logged in to post comments on this website.

Login or Register.

Please take a few minutes to complete this survey. It will help us find out how you use the website so we can keep improving it for you. Everyone who completes the survey will get the chance to win £50.